While Hulu has not officially released the full plot for Season 5 of Only Murders in the Building, the story is expected to pick up from the cliffhanger ending of Season 4. Here’s what we can anticipate based on available hints and casting news:
Table of Contents
Where Season 4 Left Off
At the end of Season 4, viewers were left with a dramatic twist involving the mysterious death of Lester, the beloved doorman of the Arconia building. Though Season 4 focused on the murder of actor Ben Glenroy (played by Paul Rudd), Lester’s sudden death hinted at a new mystery brewing within the building’s walls.
Season 5 Storyline – What to Expect
1. The New Murder Mystery Season 5 will likely revolve around solving Lester’s death. Was it natural or was foul play involved? Given the show’s history, fans can expect another twist-filled investigation full of red herrings, suspicious neighbors, and unexpected revelations.
2. Mob Connections & Sofia Caccimelio Téa Leoni’s character, Sofia Caccimelio, a mob wife, is expected to play a major role in the upcoming storyline. Her presence could introduce a more dangerous and high-stakes element to the show—possibly involving criminal organizations or a larger conspiracy that reaches beyond the Arconia.
3. Personal Struggles & Relationships: Mabel (Selena Gomez) may explore a new phase in her personal and professional life, especially after stepping more confidently into crime-solving.
Charles (Steve Martin) and Oliver (Martin Short) could face deeper questions about aging, relationships, and loyalty as they juggle real life with their podcast adventures.
4. Bigger Stakes for the Trio With fame from their podcast growing and more eyes on their investigations, the trio might deal with media pressure, police interference, or even copycats trying to exploit their success. Expect more humor, heartfelt moments, and character growth alongside the suspense.
New Characters to Drive the Plot
The addition of stars like Renée Zellweger, Keegan-Michael Key, and possibly Logan Lerman hints that new suspects, neighbors, or rivals will enter the picture—each with secrets and motives that will keep fans guessing all season long.
Will the Podcast Continue?
Yes! The murder-solving podcast, central to the show’s charm, is expected to continue, possibly evolving into something bigger with sponsors, interviews, and new formats.
Summary
Season 5 of Only Murders in the Building will likely offer another tightly woven mystery centered around Lester’s death and potentially linked to organized crime. With new characters, twists, and emotional arcs, the trio’s latest investigation promises to be their most challenging—and entertaining—yet.